Book Organised Play Events

Huge Summer Sale. Shop Now

Pokémon Card Grading Explained: PSA vs ACE vs CGC

Pokémon Card Grading Explained: PSA vs ACE vs CGC

Joshua Todd |

You've just pulled an absolute beauty.

Maybe it's a Charizard Special Illustration Rare. Maybe it's a vintage holographic card you've had tucked away since childhood. Or perhaps it's a Pokémon that means absolutely nothing to anybody else, but you love it.

Naturally, there's only one question on your mind.

Should I get this graded?

And then comes the second question.

Who on earth should I send it to?

PSA? ACE? CGC?

With different grading standards, prices, turnaround times and slabs to choose from, deciding where to send your Pokémon cards can feel almost as complicated as pulling them in the first place.

Fortunately, we're here to help.

In this guide, we'll explain how Pokémon card grading works, compare three popular grading companies and help you decide whether grading your cards is actually worth the money.

Spoiler alert: not every card needs grading.

Even if it's shiny.

What Is Pokémon Card Grading?

Pokémon card grading is the process of having a trading card professionally authenticated and assessed for its condition.

You send your card to a grading company, where it's examined for things like centring, corners, edges and surface condition.

The company then assigns a grade, usually on a scale from 1 to 10, before encapsulating the card inside a protective plastic case.

Collectors commonly call these cases slabs.

The result is a card that's been independently assessed, protected and given a certification number that buyers can usually verify online.

For collectors, grading can serve several purposes:

  • Protecting valuable or sentimental cards.

  • Providing an independent assessment of condition.

  • Making certain cards easier to sell.

  • Potentially increasing resale value.

  • Creating a collection of matching graded cards.

And, of course, there's something undeniably satisfying about seeing your favourite Pokémon sitting inside a beautiful slab.

How Are Pokémon Cards Graded?

Although grading companies have their own standards, most assess four main areas.

1. Centring

Centring refers to how evenly the artwork is positioned within the card's borders.

If one border is noticeably thicker than the opposite border, the card is off-centre.

This is particularly important when chasing the highest grades.

And yes, you can pull a card directly from a brand-new booster pack that's already badly centred.

Thanks, Pokémon.

2. Corners

Graders examine all four corners for whitening, wear, damage and imperfections.

Even tiny defects can influence the final grade.

3. Edges

The edges are inspected for whitening, chipping, rough cuts and other imperfections.

This is especially important for older Pokémon cards that have spent years being shuffled, traded or stored without protection.

4. Surface

The card's surface is checked for scratches, dents, print lines and other defects.

Some damage is almost invisible until you examine the card under strong lighting.

A card can look absolutely perfect in a binder and still have surface imperfections that prevent it from receiving a top grade.

What Does a PSA 10 Actually Mean?

A PSA 10 is the company's Gem Mint grade.

It's one of the most sought-after grades in Pokémon collecting, particularly for valuable cards.

However, grading standards vary between companies.

A PSA 10 isn't necessarily identical to an ACE 10 or a CGC 10.

Each company applies its own criteria, tolerances and grading methodology.

And although grading aims to provide a consistent assessment, it still involves professional judgement.

That means you should never assume that a card graded 10 by one company would automatically receive a 10 elsewhere.

PSA Grading: The Established Favourite

PSA, short for Professional Sports Authenticator, is one of the best-known names in trading card grading.

Its distinctive red-and-white labels are instantly recognisable.

If you've spent any time browsing expensive Pokémon cards on eBay, you've almost certainly encountered PSA slabs.

Why Do Collectors Choose PSA?

One of PSA's biggest strengths is its established secondary market.

There are extensive historical sales records for PSA-graded Pokémon cards, making it easier to research prices and compare grades.

For collectors planning to sell valuable cards, this can be particularly useful.

PSA also has a widely recognised grading scale, with PSA 10 Gem Mint being especially popular among Pokémon collectors.

What Are the Downsides of PSA?

Depending on the service level, grading can be expensive and turnaround times can be lengthy.

UK collectors also need to consider submission arrangements, shipping, insurance and any intermediary fees.

PSA has expanded its European grading operations, but the exact submission route and service availability should always be checked before sending cards.

Who Is PSA Best For?

We'd particularly consider PSA when:

  • You're grading a valuable card primarily for resale.

  • You want to compare your card against an established sales history.

  • You're building a matching PSA collection.

  • You value the familiarity and recognition of PSA slabs.

That doesn't mean PSA is always the best option.

But it's certainly a strong contender.

ACE Grading: A UK-Based Alternative

ACE Grading has become a popular option among UK Pokémon collectors.

Being based in the UK makes it an appealing choice for collectors who would rather use a domestic grading company.

ACE is also particularly well known for its presentation options, including labels designed to complement the artwork of the graded card.

And let's be fair, some of those matching labels look fantastic.

Why Do Collectors Choose ACE?

One of ACE's biggest attractions is its range of presentation options.

Collectors can choose different label styles, including artwork-matched designs where available.

For someone building a personal collection, the appearance of the finished slab can be just as important as the grade itself.

ACE also offers different service levels, allowing customers to choose between lower-cost submissions and faster processing options.

What Are the Downsides of ACE?

Although ACE has developed a following, its graded cards don't necessarily command the same resale prices as equivalent PSA cards.

That doesn't mean ACE cards are worth less in every situation.

It means collectors should compare actual completed sales rather than assuming identical grades from different companies have identical market values.

It's also important to review the company's submission terms, insurance arrangements and compensation policies before sending valuable cards.

Who Is ACE Best For?

ACE could be a particularly good choice if:

  • You're based in the UK.

  • You love custom or artwork-matched labels.

  • You're grading cards primarily for your personal collection.

  • You want a range of service levels.

  • You prefer using a UK-based grading company.

A quick note from JET Cards: We're an ACE-approved grading drop point, so we're familiar with the submission process. However, we'd still encourage collectors to compare all available grading companies and choose the one that best suits their cards and priorities.

CGC Grading: A Strong Option for Collectors

CGC Cards is another established grading company with a significant presence in the trading card market.

Its slabs are particularly recognisable for their clean presentation, and its grading system includes a distinction between Gem Mint 10 and Pristine 10.

What's the Difference Between CGC Gem Mint 10 and Pristine 10?

CGC uses separate designations for these grades.

A Gem Mint 10 represents an exceptionally well-preserved card.

Pristine 10 is a higher distinction reserved for cards meeting CGC's particularly demanding requirements.

The Pristine 10 label is especially attractive to collectors who enjoy chasing the very highest grades.

Of course, achieving one isn't easy.

If every card came back Pristine 10, there wouldn't be much point in having the grade.

Why Do Collectors Choose CGC?

CGC offers a recognised grading system, distinctive labels and a market for high-grade trading cards.

Its Pristine 10 designation can be particularly appealing for collectors who want to distinguish exceptional cards from standard Gem Mint examples.

What Are the Downsides of CGC?

As with ACE, resale values can differ from equivalent PSA-graded cards.

The grading fee, turnaround time and submission process also depend on the service selected.

UK customers should review CGC's current UK submission options and associated charges.

Who Is CGC Best For?

CGC may be a good choice if:

  • You particularly like the appearance of CGC slabs.

  • You're interested in chasing Pristine 10 grades.

  • You want a recognised alternative to PSA.

  • You're building a CGC-focused collection.

PSA vs ACE vs CGC: Which Is Best?

So, which company should you actually choose?

The answer depends on what you're hoping to achieve.

Your priority Company worth considering
Established resale market PSA
Artwork-matched labels ACE
UK-based grading ACE
Pristine 10 designation CGC
Personal collection Any of the three
Maximising resale value Compare completed sales first

These are general considerations, not guarantees.

A valuable card might sell better in one company's slab, while another card might have stronger demand elsewhere.

And if you're grading purely for your own collection?

Choose whichever slab you actually like looking at.

It really can be that simple.

How Much Does Pokémon Card Grading Cost in the UK?

This is where things get interesting.

Grading costs vary considerably depending on the company, the service level, the value of your card and how quickly you want it returned.

At the time of writing, ACE offers several service levels, including lower-cost options and premium expedited services.

PSA and CGC also offer multiple grading tiers, with different fees and value limits.

However, published prices and turnaround times can change frequently.

Rather than relying on an old price list, we'd recommend checking the official websites before submitting.

Don't Forget the Additional Costs

The advertised grading fee isn't always the total amount you'll pay.

Depending on your submission, there may also be costs for shipping, insurance, handling, special labels or other services.

Some companies also have different fees for particularly valuable cards.

Make sure you understand the full cost before deciding whether grading is worthwhile.

Is Pokémon Card Grading Actually Worth It?

Here's the big question.

And the answer is...

Sometimes.

Helpful, we know.

But there's a reason we can't give you a simple yes or no.

Grading can increase the value of certain Pokémon cards, particularly when they receive desirable grades.

However, grading also costs money, takes time and comes with no guarantee of receiving the grade you're hoping for.

Let's look at an example.

Example: Should You Grade a £50 Pokémon Card?

Imagine you own a Pokémon card worth £50 ungraded.

You research recent sales and discover that:

  • Ungraded copies sell for around £50.

  • Copies graded 9 sell for around £60.

  • Copies graded 10 sell for around £120.

These are hypothetical prices for illustration, not values for a specific card.

At first glance, grading sounds like a brilliant idea.

Turn £50 into £120!

Easy money, right?

Not quite.

You still need to pay the grading fee, any shipping costs and potentially selling fees.

And what happens if the card receives a 9 instead of a 10?

Suddenly, you might have spent £20 or more to add very little value to the card.

You could even end up worse off financially.

Our Advice

Before grading a Pokémon card, check recent completed sales for:

  1. The card in ungraded condition.

  2. The same card graded 9.

  3. The same card graded 10.

  4. Equivalent grades from your chosen grading company.

Then compare those values against the total grading cost.

Most importantly, be realistic about the grade your card might receive.

If a card only makes financial sense as a perfect 10, you're taking a gamble.

Should You Grade Modern or Vintage Pokémon Cards?

Both can be worth grading, but there are some differences to consider.

Modern Pokémon Cards

Modern cards can be excellent grading candidates, particularly popular Illustration Rares, Special Illustration Rares and other chase cards.

If you're still getting your head around Illustration Rares, Special Illustration Rares and all those shiny stars, check out our complete guide to Pokémon card rarities.

However, modern cards aren't automatically perfect just because they've come straight from a booster pack.

Factory defects, print lines, centring issues and corner damage can all affect the grade.

Vintage Pokémon Cards

Vintage Pokémon cards can be particularly interesting grading candidates.

Older cards may have significant collector demand, and condition can have a substantial influence on their value.

However, vintage cards have often spent years being handled, played with or stored in less-than-ideal conditions.

A childhood Charizard might hold enormous sentimental value, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's going to receive a high grade.

Especially if it spent 20 years living in a shoebox.

How to Check Your Pokémon Cards Before Grading

Before sending anything away, we'd recommend giving each card a careful inspection.

Start with clean hands and a well-lit surface.

Examine the card from different angles, paying particular attention to:

  • Centring on the front and back.

  • Whitening around the edges.

  • Damage to the corners.

  • Surface scratches and print lines.

  • Dents, creases or other imperfections.

Avoid rubbing or attempting to polish the card.

You could easily cause more damage than you're trying to remove.

If you're unsure about a card's condition, compare it against examples of graded cards and review the grading company's published standards.

Just remember that your own assessment isn't a guaranteed prediction of the final grade.

How Should You Prepare Pokémon Cards for Grading?

Once you've decided to submit a card, proper preparation is essential.

Follow your chosen grading company's packaging instructions carefully.

Typically, this involves placing the card into an appropriate soft sleeve and then into a recommended semi-rigid holder or other approved protection.

Make sure the card is secure without being forced into a tight sleeve or holder.

Use suitable protective packaging for transport, and consider the declared value and insurance arrangements.

Never assume that a grading company's standard compensation limit will automatically cover the full value of an expensive card.

And please, don't just put your £500 Charizard loose inside a padded envelope.

We beg you.

Does Grading Protect Your Pokémon Cards Forever?

Grading slabs provide useful physical protection, but they're not indestructible.

They can still be scratched, cracked or damaged.

Cards can also be affected by unsuitable storage conditions.

We'd recommend keeping graded cards away from excessive heat, direct sunlight, moisture and anything else that could cause long-term damage.

If you're building a valuable collection, proper storage and appropriate insurance are worth considering.

Can You Sell Graded Pokémon Cards?

Absolutely.

Graded Pokémon cards are regularly bought and sold through marketplaces, specialist retailers and collector communities.

However, the price depends on much more than the number printed on the label.

The Pokémon, expansion, artwork, rarity, grading company, grade and overall market demand can all influence value.

When researching prices, use completed sales rather than active listings.

Just because somebody has listed a PSA 10 for £2,000 doesn't mean anybody has actually paid £2,000 for it.

We could list a Common Magikarp for £10,000 tomorrow.

Unfortunately, that wouldn't make us rich.

Our Verdict: PSA, ACE or CGC?

If you're primarily grading valuable Pokémon cards with resale in mind, PSA is certainly worth considering because of its established market and recognisable slabs.

If you're building a personal collection and love artwork-matched labels, ACE offers an appealing UK-based option.

And if you're interested in CGC's grading system and the distinction of a Pristine 10, CGC deserves a look.

But there isn't one perfect grading company for every collector.

The right choice depends on your cards, your budget and what you want to achieve.

Our biggest piece of advice? Don't grade a card simply because you think you should.

Grade it because it makes financial sense, because you want to protect it, or because you genuinely love the card.

Those are all perfectly good reasons.

Final Thoughts: Is Your Next Pokémon Card Worth Grading?

Pokémon card grading can be a brilliant part of collecting.

There's something incredibly satisfying about getting a favourite card back in a slab, especially when it receives the grade you were hoping for.

But grading isn't a guaranteed way to make money.

Research the card, inspect its condition, compare the grading companies and understand the full costs before submitting.

And if you're still unsure?

There's absolutely nothing wrong with keeping a beautiful Pokémon card in a binder.

Sometimes that's exactly where it belongs.

If you're more into ripping packs and booster boxes, why not check out our guide to whether you should open Pokémon booster boxes or keep them sealed? We promise not to judge your pack-opening addiction. Much.

Looking for Your Next Pokémon Card?

Whether you're hunting for a card to grade, collecting your favourite Pokémon or simply fancy opening a few booster packs, JET Cards has plenty to explore.

Browse our Pokémon singles and graded cards, or visit us at the JET Cards Gaming Centre.

And here's a question for you:

What's the best grade you've ever received on a Pokémon card?

Or, perhaps more importantly, what's the grade you were absolutely convinced would be a 10... until it came back an 8?

We've all been there.

Leave a comment